Funny story with this lipstick- I ordered the Kathleen Lights lip bundle, and was accidentally sent the IluvSarahii set instead. When I told them about it, they said I could keep it, so yay for bonus reviews for all of you!
Color: 951 is a really beautiful warm medium brown shade. I’d say it has a little more depth than your average nude, but is still pink enough to be less intimidating for those scared of a traditional brown.
Finish: The Ultra Satin lips have an almost-matte finish that never quite dry down. It’s like a demi-matte with just the slightest bit of sheen to keep from the traditional flat finish that most liquid lipsticks have.
Packaging: The tube of this lipstick is just like their standard tubes, but the cap is a beautiful gold instead of their traditional silver. The printing on it is also gold versus their traditional holographic text, and it says “iluvsarahii X Colourpop” to notate the collaboration.
Applicator: The applicator on this is standard for Colourpop; a basic doefoot. While mine does fray a bit and doesn’t sit smooth, I had no difficulties at all with getting straight lines.
Application: I found the application of this particular shade to be very easy. The color is opaque in one swipe and easy to get a smooth, straight line, even on the edges.
It does remain slightly tacky because it never truly dries down, so in the first few minutes after application it feels a bit off until you get used to it. If I hadn’t been paying specific attention to that detail, I wouldn’t have felt this on my lips at all.
There is no discernible scent with the Colourpop lipsticks; it smells a bit like chemicals, but the scent isn’t offensive and did not linger. I could never smell it once it was on my lips.
This color had a tendency to emphasize the texture of my lips, especially when they were dry, so even upon application within a few minutes you could see each crack and crevice. This can be helped by either having smoother lips than I do, or exfoliating/using balm the night before use to minimize the clinging!
Transfer: One thing that I’ve noticed with all Colourpop Ultra Satin lips is that they transfer quite a bit; this one was no exception. I found that it would come off on my water bottle after just drinking water, and always came off on my food. I left lipstick everywhere, especially as the first layer wore down. After it faded off a bit the amount that transferred did lessen, so if you blotted right away you would probably have less issues than I did!
Fading: Despite the fact that the amount of transfer was frustrating, I was surprised that the fading wasn’t too bad. After eating a larger or more messy meal, there was a definite need for reapplication, otherwise I had a ring of product around the outside of my lips, and my lips looked even stranger due to the line emphasis. However, just wearing throughout the day with drinking, breakfast and a non-messy lunch means that this lip product would still look good!
One thing I did notice was that the product built up a bit as the day wore on, which meant that I had patches of slightly orange dry spots on my lips. This is something that I had only noticed when my lips were especially dry, so again if you properly moisturize beforehand I don’t think you’ll have this issue.
Comfort: Unlike a normal matte liquid lipstick, this never dries down completely. Because of that, I could always feel a bit of stick when I pushed my lips together and I felt more aware of it being on my lips. That said, it remained incredibly comfortable throughout the duration of wear. It’s not hydrating, but it’s also not drying at all and is a great formula for those who hate liquid lipsticks for the feeling of them.
Overall: I love the comfort of the ultra satins, but the fading and transfer of them is definitely frustrating. I think part of the problem is that I have yet to try a lighter shade; both Stud and this one are a bit darker, more brown-toned nudes so it’s not a surprise that the appearance and wear would also be similar.
I haven’t quite decided if I’ll keep this yet, but I’m leaning a bit towards yes. It’s really beautiful, and if you love this formula and can put up with the fading, you absolutely will not be disappointed!
Price Point: If you really love this color but don’t want to purchase the bundle, you can buy the single lipstick here for $7. However, if you’re looking to buy a few lipsticks and save some money, you can buy the whole kit here!
Have you ever tried the Ultra Satin formula from Colourpop?